Nae Chance

Union_Jack-NO

It’s raining so a rant for your amusement, of course it’s all bullying! NOT from AK!! Just a very good pal.

Why on earth would a Scot who gave England an intelligent Stuart Monarch, to replace a barren semi legitimate Tudor, so that England, Wales & Ireland became part of the Scottish Isles, give up what they had so long desired, a united kingdom under Scottish rule. James VI sensibly told the Saxons that they better thole the arrangement and accept that they were to be British, e.g. a subset of the people that Edward thought he had conquered, and expect them to fight under a Union Jack with a thinly disguised St Andrews Cross as its main element.

Then to better exploit the resources of England corrupt and avaricious Scots united the parliaments and exploited both the resources and English market to build an industrial power, and spread Scottish influence and products throughout the World, making the Scots the wealthiest and most successful sub set of the British Diaspora. Scots governed many of the colonies, and governed England much of the time. It could be said that the UK operated mostly in the interest of Scotland, and probably still does. A Scot is welcome almost everywhere.

What rational that has any merit justifies breaking this arrangement which has benefited Scots, and economic immigrants like ourselves. It is very hard to be positive about a thoroughly crap idea.

This Brave Heart syndrome, that seems to have revived the Jacobite cause, would leave Scotland separated from the wealth and economic strength Scots did so much to develop. It’s like cutting off a nation’s nose to spite its face. The fact that the Norman usurpers of both countries found common cause and continued to exploit the indigenous population of both countries seems to be written out of the narrative. Class divisions and the divide between rich and poor will remain, and probably become more acute. The problem is not one of nationality but of economic power and exploitation, which has to fought on an international scale.

The whole discussion lead by the media and purportedly artistic community based on cultural identity is almost daft; the culture of Scotland was exported by Scottish landlords to make way for sheep. It is more honoured among the consequent Diaspora than here. The Gaelic culture barely survives, and the present Scottish culture only prospers as a local variety of Anglophone culture. Local dialect has largely disappeared. Sikhs, Moslems and Poles probably have a more coherent cultural identity. Many of the media arguments are redolent of insecurity not confidence.

I would be convinced if the former SLF conducted its business in Gaelic and landlords spoke to estate workers in Gaelic, rather than the language of the dominant minority and exploiter being the lingua franca.

The idea that Scotland could not be independent is a non argument, of course it could operate independently, and it could eventually make itself prosperous. It was only ever poor because those in power exploited those who generated the wealth in the name of governing and defending the country, that cost will increase not diminish.

What is going to change, except that 4 million people will have to bear the cost rather than 65 million? When we look at the cost of establishing the Irish State, corruption, de population and civil war dragged on for decades and depopulation almost equalled that of the Potato Famine.

God knows what it will be like to live in Scotland if the vote is very close. It will split the country and vile spirits of past religious, ethnic and class conflicts will get a new lease of life. All foreigners are resented in the East End of Glasgow, and that in a community of people of Irish, Italian, English backgrounds who came in desperation as economic immigrants, who while thinking themselves Scottish know almost nothing about Scotland, and are more gripped by religious and political divisions that have their roots elsewhere. There are people on the Housing Committee who might vote Yes if they thought it would result in desperate immigrants/refugees having a free bus pass withdrawn and access to any sort of social benefit denied. Anybody who is ahead of them in a Dr’s surgery is self evidently, an immigrant exploiting the health service, not an sick person in need of medical care. They resent the presence of the thousands of Chinese who currently enable the Universities to survive while educating the indigenous population for free. Under the surface there is a stinking swamp.

Will Scotland become a fairer and more equal country, no. Will it be able to get rid of nuclear weapons, not for a long time. Will it be able to operate effectively in the short term as a completely isolated currency, no. Will it get the wealth from oil, no.

In international law breaking up a country to secure exclusive the benefit of a natural resource is thought to be illegal, and has resulted in wars throughout Africa and South America. In fact it could be said that Germany’s invasion of the resource rich areas close to its borders it order to increase its economic power was the reason for WWII, and defending or integrating its European Diaspora just an excuse. Will Shetland & Orkney remain as part of Scotland, probably not.

If Russia can dismember Ukraine, annex Crimea, and gain control of the Donetsk coal basin, leaving an agrarian rump, then the remnant UK can quite easily justify taking control over any part of what is currently defined as Scotland if the vote for independence is dominantly no. Who puts the boots on the ground to defend it, a militia with pitch forks? What we currently think of as Scotland could be dismembered. The supporters of independence could end up with a theme park of heather and mountains owned by foreigners, who do not pay tax in any jurisdiction, but exert extraordinary influence. In fact the last people Scotland wants are the ones on behalf of whom the state has operated for centuries.

A new future, yes, as a minor rump economy open to exploitation by every foreign carpet bagger, from Donald Trump to oil companies, Norwegian fish farming firms and Swedish forestry and pulp firms. After golf courses, wait for gambling casinos and health spars, served by cringing indigenes dressed in tartan and tweed, on a no hour’s contract. Will the financial sector remain strong, yes, but as a tax haven for people making money elsewhere? Will it produce wealth for the people of Scotland, no, it will be the location for hedge funds and foreign investment operations and brass plates on doors, like Monaco, good for a few.

 

 

More from the Pyrenees

More from the Pyrenees but on the best winter week that Ben Nevis experienced this winter.

Check out Remi’s website for more inspiration.

Hello Alan,

Eveything OK ? I send you a few pictures of the routes I climbed with my client for your blog if you want.

We were so lucky with these incredible conditions !Last week was very wet I heard…

Everything ok here in France, I could climb in Gavarnie last week (20th March) near home, a place you might already know, if not you should !

Also : one day I found at the bottom of Orion an old Mountain Technology piolet, probably dropped the day before from North-East Buttress by someone (I found it the 12 of march). I left it in the entrance of the hut if the holder wants to get it, it probably has a sentimental value !

I will send you soon our dates for next year and thanks again for everything.

Rémi

 

‘Full on’ Scottish with a dash of French

‘Full on’ Scottish with a dash of French

Hello Alan !

We are the two french mountain rescuers from Pyrenees who came on mid march. Here is little blog spot on our trip, Enjoy the picture, some little sentences in English but for the most you will work your French 🙂 Hope to see you again in the next years … to rock climb ?

Thanks for the stay, it was perfect.

These two guys entered into the spirit of winter climbing and travelled all over the place to sample what was on offer in a period of very unsettled weather. Very well done and a good summary of what foreign climbers have come to expect and enjoy about Scottish winter.

Skye Ridge

A fine day out on the Skye Ridge with Mike Lates of Skye Guides and Simon. The weather, although overcast, stayed dry 99% of the time and was better than expected. Still plenty of snow patches, which although they do not cause problems underfoot can be used to brew up if you are carrying a small stove.

Superb late season mountains

aonach mor

Glorious Aonach Mor

Thanks to Spike Sellers for this shot, as he enjoys a day off from guiding and goes ski-ing instead.

Blocking High:)

  • A big blocking high pressure is approaching from up north as the week progresses. Rock climbing is cancelled for now, yippeee! The accommodation is starting to fill up.

A very fine weekend

We have had a very fine weekend as can be see by the photo taken today. The climbing conditions are good and bad and it depends on where you go. One team returning to the accommodation said the East Face of Aonach Mor was very poor, with nothing consolidated on Morwind. Another on the West Face and Golden Oldy had a great time by starting late and following the foot steps of the ‘snow plough’ team ahead of them. I dare say that Tower Ridge and such like will be good if you scan the various blogs. One team backed off of going to Orion Face due to suspect snow conditions on the approach slopes. The avalanche risk is all over the place in pockets, so be very careful to stick to the hard neve if possible. The ski touring will be very good and the upcoming week looks promisingly cold for a change. We have plenty of space at Calluna if you fancy heading north.

Crocus and Cornice and the big ‘White Rhino’

Had an extensive chat with the French person who went 300m when Number Four Gully cornice collapsed underneath him. He is an extremely experienced mountaineer, who comes to Nevis most winters and I have got to know over many seasons. He was around three or four metres back from the edge and had seen from the side that the cornice was not undercut. The fracture happened at least a metre behind him and blocks the size of a garage slid down. At the moment my opinion is that no climbs beneath cornices should be attempted. People on the plateau may trigger a release, if you do not! Even though there was no overhang on the cornice, it is clear that a hidden weakness existed and has been produced by the continuous wintry storms over the last three months. Plenty of action all over the Minus and Orion faces, where no serious cornice risk exists. I’d advise avoiding anything at the top of Observatory Gully, including around Hadrian’s Wall for the time being. Rubicon Wall (Observatory Buttress) area has been climbed a lot with careful planning on the exit by staying on the higher crest overlooking Point Five Gully. Better safe than sorry. The climber is okay with a broken lower leg. On the same day, Graham Moss (SAIS forecaster) felt that a number of the big cornice on Nevis released spontaneously. I don’t think Point Five has been climbed much at all (if any) due to the looming nature of the cornices. Clearly some sensible people out there who are still alive.

On a gentler note I had a great day with Smiler and Colin on Heatwave in Glen Nevis. We did the harder variant using Vampire second pitch. All climbing at around Hard Severe. Today the weather is misty and damp as a weak front moves through. It could be an inversion though (?).

At last!

Sunshine

Sunshine

Hi Alan. Today we climbed Mercury another routes climbed include -3 Gully, observatory ridge and buttress, usual ridges and stuff on the Boulder. Everyone reporting good conditions. Still some big cornices around. Thanks to Chris Thorne working for Richard Bentley from the CIC Hut for this short report.

Lost Petzl Ecrin climbing helmet

If anyone finds a white Petzl Ecrin climbing helmet on Ben Nevis, possibly around the ordinary ‘mountain track’, the owner would like it returned thanks. Contact myself please.